Democrats Propose New Tax On Stock Trades (H.R. 1068)

The Democrats (with the exception of the tax-cutting John F. Kennedy) have the same solution to every problem that comes up: taxes, taxes and more taxes which means that they have not had an original idea since Franklin Delano Roosevelt. Pretty soon, they are going to have a tax for everything.

For example, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts is actully considering an idea which taxes motorists based on how many miles they drive on roads and highways.

In that style, eight Congressional Democrats have introduced a bill (HR 1068) that will tax transfers of stocks and other securities on the market. They claim it is a vehicle by which Wall Street will pay the taxpayer back for the $700 billion bailout monies, but a look at the bill itself will show otherwise:


`(a) Imposition of Tax- There is hereby imposed a tax on each covered securities transaction an amount equal to the applicable percentage of the value of the security involved in such transaction.

`(b) By Whom Paid- The tax imposed by this section shall be paid by the trading facility on which the transaction occurs.

`(c) Applicable Percentage- For purposes of this section–

`(1) IN GENERAL- The term `applicable percentage’ means the lesser of–

`(A) the specified percentage, or

`(B) 0.25 percent.

Did you notice the “By Whom” sub-section? These socialist Dems actually think that the trading facility is going to pay those costs out of pocket! The truth is, the trading facility will simply pass that cost on to the stock-holder in the form of higher trading fees.

When will these libs get a clue about economic reality?

Here is another example of the fantasyland that the Democrats live in. The stated objective of this bill is to “pay back” the taxpayer. But what is written in the bill, again, shows something completely different:

(8) All revenue generated by this transfer tax should be deposited in the general fund of the Treasury of the United States, scaled to meet the net cost of these bailouts, and phase out when the cost of the bailouts are repaid.

First of all, sending this money into the “general fund of the Treasury of the Untied States” means that it could get spent on anything that the government wants, and thus, does not have to be spent “paying back” the taxpayer. Knowing the Democrats, their intention was never for any such thing.

Second, the “phase out” is laughable since the Dems will never allow any tax to expire nor will they ever vote to repeal one. Plus, if they keep using this money for something other than the stated intention of this bill (i.e. to “pay back” the taxpayer) they can claim that the goal’s of this new tax have not been reached and therefore will be able to spin a reason as to why the tax must remain in place.

Further, the true culprit of the Wall Street financial crisis is the 1977 Community Re-investment Act. Before anything can be done to restore Wall Street, the CRA must be repealed.

This is nothing more than another socialist bill which the Dems want to use as a mechanism for Barack Obama’s stated objective of redistributing wealth. It must die before it serves to wreak even more havoc on our economy.

The eight Democrats are: Mr. Defazio, Mr. Welch, Ms. Sutton, Mr. Capuano, Mr. Wu, Mr. Stark, Ms. Delauro, and Ms. Edwards.

You can access the bill on-line here:

Let Wall Street Pay For Wall Street’s Bailout Act Of 2009
Library Of Congress
February 13, 2009

3 Responses

  1. You lost me when you failed to point out that the Republicans answer to everything, is tax cuts.

    You lost me even more with the ridiculous…. “These socialist Dems”.

    You guys created the mess we’re now in, don’t try to suggest that you suddenly have the answers.

    • futiledemocracy,

      It is true that the Republicans were not fiscally Conservative during the Bush years (something that many Conservatives, including myself, were angry about back then), but that does not mean that they are totally to blame.

      You failed to notice that the 1977 Community Re-investment Act was the orginal progenitor of the Wall Street financial crisis. (Look it up here: Go look in a history book and you will see that the liberal Democrats were in control of the entire Federal Government at the time (and even had a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate). So, your assertion that “you guys created this mess” doesn’t stand up to the facts of history.

      In fact, history shows that when tax rates go down, the economy expands. This was proven by John F. Kennedy, Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush. The tax cuts of 2001 allowed an economic expansion that lasted over six years until rising global energy prices and the Wall Street credit crunch brought it to an end.

      History also shows that when tax rates go up and government spending increases, the economy goes into the tank. This was proven by Franklin Delano Roosevelt (who made the Great Depression last ten years longer than it should have), Lyndon Johnson, Jimmy Carter and will soon be proven again by Barack Obama and the socialists who now control Congress.

      It hasn’t even been a month and Obama and the Democrats have already tripled the deficit and are set to waste over $1 trillion dollars. Even the Bush Administration wasn’t able to accomplish that in such a short time period. All that money the Dems are wasting will have to be paid back by our children and grandchildren.

      I am sorry that I “lost you” by pointing out the facts of history. Perhaps if you would more thoroughly educate yourself on such matters instead of just spouting out broad-brushed accusations and vague generalities, you might not be so easily “lost.”

  2. Bonjour,

    Je suis Antoine Rezvani et je propose des sites internet areswebstudio pas cher grace a la sous traitance offshore.
    N’hesitez pas a me contacter : ares web studio

    A bientot


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: